sales interviewer how to's

Unlocking Sales Success: The Crucial Role of the Interviewer in the Sales Hiring Process

In the high-stakes world of sales hiring, the role of the interviewer is paramount. 

It’s not just about finding someone who fits the job description, but identifying the true Sales Superstars who can fill the prospect pipeline, drive revenue, and build lasting customer relationships. 

In this article, we’ll delve into the critical role of the sales interviewer and focus on crafting the right questions to reveal a candidate’s true potential. Let’s get started!

Unraveling the Sales Interviewer’s Purpose

The primary goal of an interviewer in the sales hiring process is threefold, and it should be limited to these three tasks only…especially in the first two sales interviews. 

This is not the time to try and sell the candidate on why they should work for you and your company! Make sure they’re the right fit for the role before you start convincing them to accept it.

Stick to these three goals…

Assessing Sales Abilities

One of the primary objectives during the interview is to figure out whether the candidate possesses the specific sales skills required for the position. These skills encompass a wide range of abilities, from persuasive communication and active listening to negotiation and problem-solving. The interviewer must explore how the candidate has utilized these skills in past sales situations and how they contributed to successful outcomes.

It’s important for interviewers to focus on the candidate’s achievements and understand the context and challenges they faced in their previous roles. 

Factors like market conditions, product complexity, and the competitive landscape can significantly impact a candidate’s sales performance. Taking these factors into account provides a more nuanced perspective on the candidate’s abilities and achievements.

A track record of success in previous sales roles is a powerful indicator of a candidate’s potential for future performance. High achievements, such as consistently meeting or exceeding sales targets, securing significant deals, or driving revenue growth, highlight the candidate’s ability to deliver results and thrive in a sales environment. 

But most importantly, you have to determine if they have the Sales DNA to get out there and sell for your unique business!

Simulating Sales Situations

In the high-pressure world of sales, the ability to perform under real-life conditions is critical. Interviewers play a pivotal role in assessing a candidate’s selling abilities by creating simulated sales situations during the interview process. These carefully crafted scenarios provide a controlled environment where candidates can showcase their sales skills, problem-solving capabilities, and interpersonal acumen.

Simulating sales situations offers several distinct advantages. 

First, it allows interviewers to observe candidates in action and provides valuable insights into their selling techniques and strategies. While resumes and past experiences may provide a glimpse of a candidate’s sales abilities, being put in an actual selling situation offers a more accurate representation of their sales skills.

For example, interviewers can evaluate how candidates handle pressure and react to challenges that commonly arise in sales. They can gauge how well candidates are able to: 

  • Respond to objections
  • Adapt to different communication styles
  • Ask great questions

These real-time observations provide a glimpse into a candidate’s critical thinking skills and their ability to navigate complex situations.

In addition to evaluating candidates, simulations also offer candidates a chance to experience the realities of the sales role they are applying for. 

Engaging in simulated sales scenarios gives candidates a glimpse of the challenges and opportunities they may encounter if selected for the position. This firsthand experience can help candidates assess their fit for the role and demonstrate their genuine interest in the job.

Evaluating Fit with the Company

In the modern business landscape, evaluating a candidate’s fit with the company has become a critical part of the hiring process…especially in sales roles. Beyond assessing a candidate’s skills and qualifications, interviewers must determine whether the individual aligns with the company’s values, culture, and long-term goals. 

Cultural fit plays a pivotal role in determining not only the candidate’s potential for success within the organization but also their ability to positively contribute to the overall team dynamics and company culture.

One of the main reasons why evaluating cultural fit is essential is the impact it has on employee satisfaction and retention. When employees align with a company’s values and culture, they tend to be more engaged, motivated, and loyal. 

This, in turn, contributes to lower turnover rates and higher productivity. In a sales-driven environment, where building and maintaining strong client relationships is key, having a team that embodies the company’s values can lead to better customer experiences and enhanced revenue.

To gauge a candidate’s fit with the company, interviewers should be mindful of the organization’s core values and culture. 

These values often reflect the principles and beliefs that guide decision-making, drive behaviors, and shape the overall work environment. During the interview process, interviewers can directly inquire about the candidate’s personal values and beliefs, seeking to identify any shared values with the company.

The Power of Open-Ended Questions

When it comes to questioning techniques, interviewers must avoid the pitfalls of leading questions that elicit a simple “yes” or “no” response….they tell you little to nothing about the candidate’s skills, experience, or willingness to sell!

Instead, open-ended questions are the key to unlocking a candidate’s genuine thoughts, insights, and problem-solving abilities.

For instance, rather than asking, “Have you achieved your sales targets consistently in your previous role?” an interviewer should frame the question as, “Could you describe some of the strategies you employed to consistently achieve your sales targets in your previous role?” 

This encourages the candidate to elaborate, providing a more comprehensive view of their achievements.

Enhancing Your Techniques…How to Interview a Sales Candidate

To make the most of your interviewing process, it’s essential to have a structured line of questioning that thoroughly evaluates a candidate’s fit for the role. 

The following articles will help you create a repeatable sales interview process that gets results:

Got questions about what specific interview questions you should be asking?!

Get your FREE copy of our interview guide, Five Sales Interview Questions You Should be Asking (That You’re Probably Not), by clicking here. 

In it, we reveal the top five questions that could make or break your sales hiring process and demonstrate the simple ways you can easily add these important questions to your sales interview process.

It’s a quick read that will help make your next sales interview a lot easier (and more successful)!


In the world of sales hiring, the role of the interviewer is to identify top-tier sales talent through astute questioning and perceptive evaluation. 

By asking open-ended questions that delve into a candidate’s experiences and thought processes, interviewers can uncover the true potential of each applicant. Remember, it’s not about being liked or selling the opportunity upfront; it’s about finding the perfect match for your company’s needs and goals.

If you’re eager to explore more in-depth strategies for sales interviews, our Sales Selection Training Program is just a click away! It’s the stress-free way to easily narrow down your candidate pool with a thorough, scientifically-backed hiring process that gets results. 

Stop wasting your time interviewing candidates who will never be successful for your company, and start hiring Sales Superstars whenever you need them. 

This impactful one-day training has everything you need to ensure your sales team is full of top-tier salespeople who get results. Click here for details.

900 400 Improve Growth
Share this article
Privacy Preferences

When you visit our website, it may store information through your browser from specific services, usually in the form of cookies. Here you can change your Privacy preferences. It is worth noting that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our website and the services we are able to offer.

We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies.